| |
|
Guidelines
for Readers
|
| |
1.
Check to see what the writer is asking for in terms of feedback,
and get into a mindset to do your part to meet the request.
Don't overstep.
2. Read the piece carefully and thoroughly. Once may not be
enough. Make notations in readable handwriting.
3. Point out problems and issues as objectively as possible.
Be specific. Offer solutions or resources if you are aware of
any. Ask questions! It's much easier to hear something like
this:
"I noticed that the point of view switched three times
in this paragraph--is that what you were trying for?
Compare that with:
"You're head-hopping---rotten technique."
You could even go a step further and suggest ways to smooth
out the POV or whatever other misstep you find.
4. Because you are a good human being, look for positive as
well as constructive items to comment upon. If something strikes
you as appropriately funny or touching or wows you, say so!
5. The evening that you share your critique, speak directly
to the writer and do so calmly and with respect.
|
|
|
|
